Table Of Contents

Finding The Best Amish Handcrafted Dining Room Furniture

When was the last time you enjoyed shopping for a new dining room? First you have a long drive to one of a dwindling number of furniture stores. The store looks huge, but when you get inside, only a small portion is set up in dining rooms. A close look at the furniture reveals shoddy workmanship, cheap materials, very poor selection, and they don’t even have anything you like. If they have any options available at all, it’s a special order and they make you feel bad for wanting something custom. And you can tell the salesperson is just on commission and doesn’t really care.

Would you be interested in the most fun experience you’ve ever had shopping for furniture? A place where they ask you what you want, then build it for you? Of course you would! Stop by Pumpkin Patch Market to begin your journey to a dining room that has been designed by you, and built by local craftsmen with a total commitment to creating heirloom pieces just for you.

Design Your Own Dining Room Table

When you enter the showroom at Pumpkin Patch Market, you may be shocked at the size. How can they have enough furniture here so you can get just what you want? The answer is, you haven’t designed it yet! Sit down with the friendly staff, and in no time, you will be involved in making choices you never thought you could make. If you already have an idea what style of furniture you like, great. But if not, it won’t take long to start narrowing it down. You can find some of our table collections online.

The design process begins by deciding how you want to use your dining space. Do you need a large family style table that will work for everyday and large gatherings? Do you prefer restaurant style, with several smaller tables in a large room? Table height is also a popular new option, with some people preferring diner height tables and chairs. Will you want accessory pieces in the dining room, such as hutches? We have those as well.

After understanding how you want to use your dining room, the design process begins. Let's look at tables first. We have at least 10 different shapes of table tops. Do you want a corner leg table, center pedestal, trestle table, double pedestal, or something different? Once you decide on the design of the table, then the styles come into play. Any of the leg designs are available in many styles, from traditional to very modern, and everything between. And you aren’t locked in to matching the top to the legs, either, If you want a different style top than the legs, we can do that, subject to any construction problems that might not let it work. 

Choosing Woods, Colors & Finish For Your New Amish Built Furniture

Now that your table is designed, there are still more choices for you! What species of wood do you want, and in what color and finish? And you will be choosing from real wood! No chipboard, particle board, or manufactured wood products are ever used in Pumpkin Patch furniture! The combinations are almost endless, and we can usually match any existing furniture you have. If you like a rough sawn surface, or a live edge, we can do that. If you want the table top of finished wood, but would like painted and distressed legs, no problem. Another thing you will need to decide is how many leaves you want for your table. Some of our customers have designed tables that are 18’ long, so a large family is not an issue. 

Don't Forget The Custom Made Chairs!

Now that your table is designed, you will need chairs. We have a huge variety of chairs to choose from. Of course you can have the chairs match the table exactly, but you don’t have to. You can choose a chair style that is complementary to the table, or one that is completely different. If you are into very rustic or shabby chic styles, you can have every chair different! It’s all up to you. If bench seating is something you like, we have benches that have leaves, so they can be extended just like the table. If you prefer upholstered chairs, we have a wide selection of fabrics to choose from, and if you want more than one type of fabric on your chairs, we can do that as well.

Completing The Amish Dining Room Furniture Order

Now that you have designed your table and chairs, let's move on to the other pieces that can complete a dining room. Servers, side tables, wine storage cabinets, china cupboards, and many other items, are all available with many hardware, wood and finish options. A visit to our showroom will also give you many choices for decorative items to give your new dining room that finished look.

The Inside Story on Amish Custom Made Furniture

By now you are probably wondering how we can provide such customized work at a price you can afford. Pumpkin Patch has created a manufacturing plan that allows us to ensure not only the highest quality, but also allow the customer the widest variety of options.

When you order a dining room from Pumpkin Patch, we call on several woodworking shops to start building your pieces. Local builders, committed to quality work, are constantly monitored to make sure the quality is up to our standards. These shops specialize in different parts of your dining room. One makes chairs, another tables, and so on. Depending what pieces you order, as many as 4 separate shops will be building your order. 

Each shop not only builds furniture, but includes those little details you may never notice, details that will enhance your ownership experience and the life of the piece. Extra reinforcements, hand selected wood, applying finish to all surfaces, and many other construction details, are standard at our shops.

The Finishing Touches on Amish Handcrafted Dining Room Furniture

After all your furniture is constructed by the different shops, it is then sent to one finishing shop, to ensure perfect matches of colors and stains. We also have an upholstery shop, which does all our fabric work.

Having this manufacturing system allows your dining room to get made by people who do the same thing every day, and have become experts. With all our builders being very local, it allows for very low transportation costs, and makes it possible for us to visit the shops any time. 

Quality Is Worth Waiting For

You might think that this system makes everything run smoothly, resulting in furniture flying out the door. And in some ways that is true.

But our furniture has become so popular with customers, that our lead time can be 8 weeks or more during our busy season. But as in most things in life, quality is worth waiting for, and our customers soon find out that waiting a few weeks was worth it, for heirloom furniture that will last for generations.

So if you need to update that ragged old dining room, stop by Pumpkin Patch Market. We will help you get started on your journey to designing your dream dining room.

"I am so happy with my new table and chairs. They were just exactly as I had wanted/ordered. Ken was so helpful and knowledgeable when placing the order and the guys that delivered and set the table up were true gentlemen. The Pumpkin Patch experience was excellent! Thank you."   

Connie N.

See what our customers are saying

November Specials
Pumpkin Patch Market in Middlebury

Shop Amish Hardwood Furniture, Sheds and Poly Furniture

Featured Local Built Shed

12 x 16 Studio w/ 7' Side Walls

Options Included in this building: The 6' x 7' garage door can be opened to bring in lawn mowers, golf carts, ect, while maintaining a stylish appearance. This building also includes vinyl siding and a metal roof. Electrical package has been added to this building including 5 Receipt Boxes, 1 Electrical Panel, and 2 Switch Boxes.

Custom Shed Designer

Do you have a design in mind? You can use our custom shed designer to get all the features and colors you want.

Featured Amish Hardwood Desks

We have several custom made sit to stand desks in stock now that are built at a local woodworking shop right here in Middlebury. A sit and stand desk is just what it sounds like, you can adjust the height of the desk electronically to use with a regular office chair, to a bar height stool or a standing height.

Cash and Carry Amish Made Desks

If you purchase a desk we have in stock, you can take it home today, or we can deliver it to your home or office. We carefully wrap your hardwood furniture in plastic and padding to ensure a safe and scratch free delivery. We can help you load each piece if you are taking it home with you, or we will bring your new furniture right to your door. We also unwrap and set it up for you if you prefer, so you can see how each feature works on your new product.

Easy Furniture Financing Options

Pumpkin Patch Market offers easy financing options on all Amish Hardwood Furniture in stock or custom orders. You can make a down payment and have monthly payments to simplify the purchasing process of your new furniture. We also accept cash and check as payment.

Custom Amish Hardwood Furniture Orders

If you want to custom order a desk, you can choose your wood species, such as hickory, oak, elm, maple or cherry. You can also customize things like stain color, chair style and drawer pulls. All our Amish built desks are made of solid hardwood with high quality hardware so they will last a lifetime. Drawer slides that don't make a sound, but hold the heaviest files, drawer pulls that feel solid and sturdy. Make your home office or your workplace a delight to spend time in with a handcrafted Amish built desk from Pumpkin Patch Market in Middlebury.

Featured Amish Hardwood Dining Sets

All our hardwood tables are made in local Amish woodworking shops and built of solid native woods. Some tables have solid tops and seat 4, 6 or 8 people. Our tables that extend with leaves can seat 4 to 24 people.  The extending table is one that many local Amish families have in their homes, having room to host a large number of friends and family is an important part of the culture. Each Pumpkin Patch Market dining table is handcrafted and made to last for generations to come. We only sell the finest of heirloom quality furniture so you can feel certain that your investment is a good choice.

Available Amish Hardwood Dining Tables and Chairs

We have several dining table and chair sets as well as some individual tables in stock for immediate purchase. We have some tables pictured that we are available now, but in stock inventory can change daily, so stop in or call to get a current list. If you want to purchase an in stock item, you may take it with you or we can deliver it to your home. Don't miss the Clearance Corner for exceptional deals, these are available for online and in store purchase.

Table Delivery Service

We carefully package and wrap your hardwood dining tables and chairs for delivery whether you transport them or we deliver. Our delivery team will unwrap, set up and inspect your furniture before they close the order to ensure that your Amish hardwood furniture is perfect in every way.

LuxCraft Poly Outdoor Furniture

LuxCraft is one of the leading manufacturers in poly furniture. The attention to detail, product warranty and quality materials are some of the reasons why we carry their products. We have a full line of poly gliders, adirondack chairs, benches, tables and more in stock now. The recent building material shortages have impacted production time, so custom orders my take up to 15 weeks.

Custom Built Pergolas and Pavilions

When you walk through our extensive outdoor showroom you will notice a variety of pergolas and pavilions. We have several designs to choose from and these outdoor structures can completely transform your outdoor living space. Ask one of our sales team for ordering information and installation.

Local Honey and Amish Peanut Butter Spread

As always we have a wide variety of gift items from local honey, amish peanut butter, wall decor and handmade candles as well.

Holiday Hours

Our regular store hours are M-F 9-5 and Sat 9-3. Our store will be closed from Nov 26-29 for Thanksgiving and Dec 24-Jan 2 Christmas and New Years.

Contact Us

Call 574-825-3312 to place an order, stop in 10532 US Hwy 20 Middlebury, IN 46540 Hours: Mon-Fri 9-5, Sat 9-3 or shop online at www.pumpkinpatchmarket.com